7 Best PetSafe ScoopFree Litter Trays (October 2026)
The best PetSafe ScoopFree litter trays include the PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills for ready-to-use replacements, the PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Cat Litter Tray for lavender-scented refills, and the Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Box for switching to a manual box.
On this page (5 sections)
The best PetSafe ScoopFree litter tray for most owners is the PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills, which arrive pre-filled with crystal litter and have a built-in plastic lining. A reusable tray can cut down on disposable tray changes, but fit varies by ScoopFree model.
A replacement tray is a model-specific part, so start with the name and version of your automatic box. If you want a broader primer on choosing a crystal cat litter box, compare its litter system and tray style before you shop.
Our picks at a glance
-
1
Best for ready-to-use replacementsPetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for lavender-scented refillsPetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Cat Litter Tray
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for switching to a manual boxArm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Box
9.5/10 our score
See it on Amazon
- 4
Check itCOSPARX Stainless Steel Reusable Litter Tray Compatible
Best for a stainless steel tray - 5
Check itMED Litter Box Liners Compatible with Pets
Best for adding a disposable liner - 6
Check itCOSPARX Reusable Cat Litter Tray Compatible
Best for a clip-on waste extender - 7
Check itPetSafe Scoop-Free Natural Litter Reusable Tray
Best for natural mineral litter
Which PetSafe ScoopFree litter tray is best for your box?
The right PetSafe ScoopFree litter tray depends on whether you want a ready-filled disposable refill, a reusable tray, or a liner for a compatible tray. Check exact model fit before choosing an alternative.
PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills: Best for ready-to-use replacements
- Fresh-scent crystal litter
- Built-in plastic lining
- Designed for ScoopFree self-cleaning litter boxes
This refill combines the tray and crystal litter in one ready-to-use replacement. Its built-in plastic lining helps contain leaks.
Pros
- Pre-filled tray
- Built-in leak-resistant lining
- Designed for ScoopFree boxes
Cons
- Disposable tray creates ongoing replacement waste
- Fresh scent may not suit every home
This is the most straightforward replacement if you want to keep using a ScoopFree self-cleaning box with crystal litter. The refill arrives pre-filled, and its plastic lining is built into the tray to help protect the floor from leaks.
PetSafe describes the crystals as 99% dust-free and low tracking. The refill is the fresh-scent option, so consider whether fragrance is welcome in the room where the box sits.
You replace the whole tray rather than emptying and cleaning a separate reusable pan. That makes the refill simple to swap, though it means discarding the tray when it is spent.
Choose this for a ready-to-use replacement with crystal litter. Before ordering, match the refill to the model you own and follow the care instructions for your box.
PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Cat Litter Tray: Best for lavender-scented refills
- Lavender-scented crystal litter
- Built-in plastic lining
- Up to about 30 days per tray in a single-cat home
This PetSafe refill offers a lavender-scented option with crystals and a built-in lining. PetSafe says each tray can last up to about 30 days in a single-cat home.
Pros
- Pre-filled replacement
- Built-in leak-proof lining
- Single-cat use guidance provided
Cons
- Lavender scent may not suit scent-sensitive households
- Tray is disposable
This refill has a similar disposable format, with lavender-scented crystals and a built-in leak-proof lining. PetSafe says one tray can last up to about 30 days in a single-cat home.
The 3-pack gives you multiple tray replacements on hand. Its low-tracking crystals are described as gentle on paws, which may help keep more litter in the tray area.
The scent is the main practical difference from the fresh-scent refill above. If your household prefers an unscented setup, compare the available options before ordering.
Pick this if you want a lavender-scented disposable refill for a compatible ScoopFree box. It is still a complete tray swap, so it suits owners who prefer not to wash a reusable tray.
Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Box: Best for switching to a manual box
- Lift-to-sift cleaning
- Works with crystal litter
- Large box measures 19 x 15 x 8 in
This is a separate manual litter box rather than a replacement tray for a ScoopFree system. Its lift-to-sift design suits someone changing to a non-automatic setup.
Pros
- Compatible with crystal litter
- Lift-to-sift cleaning
- Made with recycled materials
Cons
- Not a ScoopFree replacement tray
- Requires moving away from the automatic box
This large Arm & Hammer box is a manual alternative, not a replacement pan for an automatic ScoopFree unit. It uses lift-to-sift cleaning and is described as compatible with crystal litter.
The box measures 19 x 15 x 8 in and can also be used with pine, pellets and clumping litter. That range can be useful if you are considering a change in litter type or want a simpler box without an automatic rake.
Arm & Hammer describes this model as made with recycled materials and says its built-in Microban protection inhibits odors. It does not include the automatic features of a ScoopFree system.
Choose it if you want to move to a separate manual box. If you need an actual ScoopFree replacement tray, choose a model-specific disposable or reusable option instead.
COSPARX Stainless Steel Reusable Litter Tray Compatible: Best for a stainless steel tray
- Reusable stainless steel tray
- Non-porous surface
- Fit excludes some ScoopFree models
This reusable stainless steel tray is designed for some PetSafe ScoopFree self-cleaning boxes. Confirm compatibility carefully because it does not fit every model.
Pros
- Reusable tray
- Non-porous stainless steel
- Can be wiped or rinsed
Cons
- Does not fit all ScoopFree models
- Litter box and litter are not included
This COSPARX option is a reusable stainless steel tray designed for some PetSafe Scoop-Free self-cleaning boxes. Its non-porous surface can be wiped or rinsed, which gives you a different cleanup routine from replacing a disposable tray.
Fit is the key limit: the tray does not fit all models and is not compatible with the new Crystal Plus Chip version. Compare your box with the compatibility image and notes before buying.
The tray is sold without the litter box or litter. Plan for the tray itself, the compatible ScoopFree unit, and the litter you intend to use.
Choose it if you want a reusable stainless steel pan and have confirmed your box is supported. If the model match is uncertain, a genuine PetSafe refill is the simpler route.
MED Litter Box Liners Compatible with Pets: Best for adding a disposable liner
- 20 bags and 20 cardboard pieces
- Drawstring closure
- Compatibility stated for Crystal Pro only
These bags and cardboard pieces are intended for compatible rectangular refill trays. Their stated fit is limited to Crystal Pro, so check your system before ordering.
Pros
- Drawstring closure
- Cardboard pieces included
- Designed for specified compatible trays
Cons
- Not compatible with Crystal Smart
- Compatibility should be confirmed before use
These MED liner bags are intended for a compatible rectangular refill tray, with cardboard pieces included as an anti-scratch barrier. The package contains 20 bags and 20 pieces of cardboard.
The fit note matters: MED specifies Crystal Pro compatibility only and says the bags do not fit Crystal Smart. The liners are not a universal substitute for a tray, so confirm the box version and tray shape before use.
The bags have drawstring closures and reinforced seams. As with any liner in an automatic box, make sure the installed material stays clear of moving parts and follows the system's instructions.
Choose these only if your model matches the stated compatibility. For help deciding whether a liner makes sense for your setup, see what a litter tray liner is used for.
COSPARX Reusable Cat Litter Tray Compatible: Best for a clip-on waste extender
- Reusable stainless steel tray
- Clip-on waste extender
- Does not fit new Smart Chip version
This COSPARX tray adds a clip-on waste extender to a reusable stainless steel design. Check your ScoopFree model first because it does not fit the new Smart Chip version.
Pros
- Reusable stainless steel tray
- Clip-on waste extender
- Wipe or rinse for cleaning
Cons
- Not compatible with new Smart Chip version
- Litter box and litter are not included
This COSPARX reusable stainless steel tray includes a clip-on waste extender. The tray is designed for some PetSafe Scoop-Free boxes, and the extender is intended to stay attached without relying on a magnet.
It does not fit the new Smart Chip version, so check your exact box before ordering. The box and litter are not included, and the tray needs to be paired with a compatible system.
The stainless steel surface can be wiped or rinsed. That may suit owners who prefer cleaning a reusable tray over replacing the full disposable refill.
Choose this if the clip-on extender is useful and your ScoopFree version is confirmed compatible. If you want a tray from PetSafe itself, compare the natural litter reusable set below.
PetSafe Scoop-Free Natural Litter Reusable Tray: Best for natural mineral litter
- Durable plastic reusable tray
- Includes 4.2 lb bag of natural litter
- PetSafe says litter controls odor for up to 21 days
This PetSafe set pairs a reusable plastic tray with natural litter made from diatomaceous earth pebbles. PetSafe says the litter reduces odors for up to 21 days.
Pros
- Reusable tray included
- Natural litter included
- No added chemicals, dyes or fragrances
Cons
- Uses a different litter material from crystal refills
- Confirm the box model fits
This PetSafe option pairs a durable plastic reusable tray with a 4.2 lb bag of natural litter. The litter uses diatomaceous earth pebbles rather than crystal refill material.
PetSafe says the pebbles reduce odors for up to 21 days and contain no added chemicals, dyes or fragrances. Rounded tray edges are designed to help prevent litter buildup, and the pebble shape is described as low mess.
The set is compatible with ScoopFree Crystal Litter Boxes. Confirm that your model supports this tray before switching, especially if you currently use a different tray or litter format.
Choose it if you want a reusable tray and prefer the included natural mineral litter. It gives you a different refill routine from the pre-filled crystal tray options.
How do disposable and reusable ScoopFree trays differ?
Disposable trays arrive ready to install and are replaced as a unit, while reusable trays need separate litter and routine cleaning. The best choice depends on how you want to manage tray changes and whether your box supports the reusable model.
The PetSafe disposable refills combine the pan, lining and crystal litter in one package. That keeps setup simple, but each replacement includes another disposable tray.
Reusable options use either stainless steel or durable plastic. Stainless steel COSPARX trays need a confirmed model match and require cleaning; PetSafe's natural litter set pairs a plastic tray with a separate litter type.
Think about the task you want to avoid. If you would rather swap a prepared tray, use a compatible disposable refill; if you prefer cleaning and reusing a pan, verify the fit and litter requirements first.
What should you check before buying a ScoopFree replacement tray?
Check the exact automatic box version, the tray's compatibility notes, and whether the package includes litter. Those details prevent a mismatch between a replacement pan and the system you already own.
Start with the model name on your box or manual. Some alternative trays explicitly exclude newer chip versions, and the MED liners specify Crystal Pro only.
Next, check what comes in the package. The PetSafe disposable trays are pre-filled, the COSPARX stainless trays do not include litter, and the natural reusable set includes a 4.2 lb bag of litter.
Finally, consider cleaning and scent. A disposable refill arrives ready to use; a reusable tray needs cleaning.
The disposable PetSafe options described here are scented, while the natural litter set is described as fragrance-free.
For a deeper look at pan shape, material and litter fit, read our guide to choosing a crystal cat litter tray.
Is a ScoopFree reusable tray right for your cat?
A reusable tray can suit you if your exact ScoopFree model supports it and you are comfortable cleaning the pan between litter changes. It may be a poor fit when compatibility is uncertain or you want a ready-filled tray.
The COSPARX models offer reusable stainless steel pans, with one including a clip-on waste extender. Their stated exclusions make model checks essential.
PetSafe's reusable option uses a durable plastic tray with natural mineral litter. It is a better match if you want that litter format rather than a stainless steel pan with crystal litter.
Keep your cat's litter preferences in mind when changing materials. A gradual transition can help you notice whether your cat accepts the new setup.
Which PetSafe ScoopFree litter tray should you choose?
Choose the PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills for a ready-filled replacement, the lavender refill if you prefer that scent, or a reusable tray only after confirming exact model compatibility. The Arm & Hammer box is for switching to a separate manual setup, while MED liners apply only to their stated compatible tray versions.
If you're comparing pan materials and shapes beyond the ScoopFree system, use the crystal cat litter tray guide to narrow your options.
Our top 3 picks at a glance
-
1
Best for ready-to-use replacements
PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refills
9.7/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
2
Best for lavender-scented refills
PetSafe ScoopFree Disposable Crystal Cat Litter Tray
9.6/10 our score
See it on Amazon -
3
Best for switching to a manual box
Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Box
9.5/10 our score
See it on Amazon
Frequently asked questions
Do reusable trays fit every PetSafe ScoopFree litter box?
No. Reusable tray compatibility depends on the exact ScoopFree model.
The COSPARX stainless steel options exclude certain versions, including Crystal Plus Chip or Smart Chip models.
Check the tray maker's compatibility notes and compare them with your box before ordering.
Can I use crystal litter in a regular litter box?
Yes. The Arm & Hammer Large Sifting Litter Box is described as compatible with crystal litter, along with pine, pellets and clumping litter.
It is a separate manual box, not a replacement tray for a ScoopFree automatic system.
How often should a disposable ScoopFree tray be replaced?
PetSafe says one lavender disposable tray can last up to about 30 days in a single-cat home. The right replacement time can vary with household use, so check the tray and follow your box instructions.
A multi-cat home may need a different schedule.
Are liners interchangeable with ScoopFree trays?
No. Liner fit can depend on the ScoopFree version and tray shape.
MED says its liners fit Crystal Pro only and are not compatible with Crystal Smart.
Check compatibility before use, and keep any liner clear of moving parts in an automatic box.
